Reddit Reddit reviews JW Pet Company Hol-ee Roller X Extreme 5 Dog Toy, 5-Inches (Colors Vary) - 43140

We found 10 Reddit comments about JW Pet Company Hol-ee Roller X Extreme 5 Dog Toy, 5-Inches (Colors Vary) - 43140. Here are the top ones, ranked by their Reddit score.

Pet Supplies
Dog Supplies
Dog Toys
Dog Toy Balls
JW Pet Company Hol-ee Roller X Extreme 5 Dog Toy, 5-Inches (Colors Vary) - 43140
Natural rubber dog toyFetch toyDurable chew toyPerfect for stuffing with treatsSuitable for medium, large, and extra-large breedsNatural rubber dog toySuitable for medium, large, and extra-large breedsDurable chew toyPerfect for stuffing with treatsSuitable for medium, large, and extra-large breeds
Check price on Amazon

10 Reddit comments about JW Pet Company Hol-ee Roller X Extreme 5 Dog Toy, 5-Inches (Colors Vary) - 43140:

u/somethingsophie · 3 pointsr/dogs

ACDs are quite the toy destroyers aren't they? Although my guy isn't quite as esteemed in the destruction field as an ACD, he is pretty bad. Here's what has survived him:

u/mudsneaker · 2 pointsr/AustralianCattleDog

So far this Hol-ee Roller X Extreme is the sole survivor out of all the various toys we've tried. As far as other toys... If it squeeks, it's dead in no time, if it's rope, it's in tatters soon enough. The ball eventually did crack after 9 months of hard core tug of wars, bought another that lasted a year before a break. These balls take the hardest abuse and just keep on going.

u/temporarily_blind · 1 pointr/germanshepherds

Ours is a power chewer. She lives for her [Kong ball] (https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B004VBC0UC/ref=oh_aui_search_detailpage?ie=UTF8&psc=1). We fill it with peanut butter and freeze it. Shes also a fan of this ball. Both haven't been destroyed yet.

u/twistedLucidity · 1 pointr/dogs

I rate the survival time of that at ~45 seconds.

I stuff ours (a cheap-o version as we expected it to get destroyed) with rags (cut-up, old tea towels) and some treats (just normal kibble). The mutt loves to shred and can pull the rags without damaging the toy. Once enough are pulled out, the treats fall.

Up-shot is, he ignores the ball and eats the treat; thus allowing me to grab it and re-pack.

\
The UK price is ~2.5 times as much!

u/kagzig · 1 pointr/dogs

Those balls are usually a hit, but I recommend buying the "Extreme" version if your dog is rough with toys.

u/Kuewee · 1 pointr/puppy101

for something rawhide-ish that isn't raw hide I'd try "Earth Animal No-Hide" though I don't know how long it'll take a dog to go through it cause my boy has a sensitive stomach so he get's these sparingly for 10-20 min tops (though I know other people who just give these to the dog and love them)

I'd also be worried about the hard cheese scratching up the throat if it's too big, but I'm a worrier and overly paranoid so idk? What I do instead is I get the West Paw Qwizl (cause my boy doesn't care about kongs but LOVES these) and find treats that fit snuggly inside so that I can have them stay by the opening but they're too snug to get out without effort on the dogs part and he just munches on that, you can also fill it with peanut butter (one that's safe for dogs, don't forget to check that) I also have a HOL-ee Roller X Extreme that he can't chew though and squeeze some cookie treats in there that are just big enough to fit and he munches on the ball to try to get them out. Besides that I just have antlers and the benebone maplestick (he loves eating sticks but he can chew through all the imitation wood ones which isn't good)

u/[deleted] · 1 pointr/Dogtraining

Your dog sounds so much like mine when he was the same age. It drove me nuts because we have a huge yard for him to run around, but when I'd let him out there he'd run for like 3 seconds and then lie down and chew on sticks. Then, when he got back in the house, he was still crazy.

Rodney was never super into toys, especially right at first. He didn't really understand how to play tug properly, and he didn't fetch (and he's a golden retriever! That's supposed to come pre-installed!). All he wanted to do was wrestle and roughhouse. Eventually, though, with enough persistence, we got him interested in fetching balls down the hall, and he LOVES tug now. It just took time for him to figure out what he liked and what the toys were for.

I bought a lot of toys for him at the beginning of his life. Spent a lot of money on them. Now I don't buy them anymore because the ones we have are holding up fine, and he likes them. His favorites are hol-ee roller, the dna toy, the IQ treat ball, big Chuck-it, and the orka ball.

The hol-ee roller and dna toy are awesome for fetch-and-tug. The only way we could get him to start fetching was to play tug with him when he brought the item back. He loves those two toys. The treat ball has been a lifesaver. We feed him his meals out of it, and it gives us some peace while we're eating as well as entertaining him. We recently got another similar toy called a snoop. This one is super awesome because it holds more food, and it's super quiet because it's made of squishy rubber, not hard plastic like the IQ ball. The orka ball is fun because it's so squishy and bouncy. He loves lacrosse balls because they're really bouncy, too. The orka is also cool because it's hollow, so you can stick treats in there. And the big Chuck-it ball has been great because he can grab onto really easy with the ridges, and I can kick a ball WAY further than I can throw it. The ball never gets lost because it's so big!

A tip to renew interest in the deer antler: boil it in chicken broth and let it dry out completely. This just gives it a new taste, and it worked when I did it for our dog.

A really good treat if you can find them is raw bones. Not the cooked ones they sell at pet stores, but uncooked bones you buy from a butcher. Ask at your local grocery store or butcher if they have bones for dogs, and if they don't know what you're talking about, ask if they have bones for making soup stock. Freeze the bones when you bring them home, and then give one to your pup! They're totally safe for dogs because unlike cooked ones, they won't splinter or break up dangerously. My dog used to spend forever licking out ever bit of marrow from the bones. They'll also clean your pup's teeth. :)

u/arisingprophet · 1 pointr/Random_Acts_Of_Amazon

Three of four

Old man!

Toy!

Toy two
It's still a black KONG type, but it's awesome.

So far I like it. I use it for tugging and it hasn't broken down yet and my dogs tug hard. I'm happy with it!