Reddit reviews Palmer's Cocoa Butter Formula Firming Butter - 10.6 fl oz

Lose weight slowly, exercise and hope for the best! Depending on how tall you are, 190 isn't terrrribly overweight in respect to dealing with saggy/loose skin.

Some people swear by this stuff but I haven't tried it.

I'm 5'5 and I've gone from 230+ down to 135 in a year and a half and I do have saggy skin on my stomach and partially on my upper, inner thighs. Pic for reference. It isn't ideal, but if you consider where I started from, my skin has performed some miracles. I think it will tighten up over time & when I lose the last bits of fat that are hanging around. (I'm pretty sure I was like 90% fat at my highest because I never, ever worked out and was extremely sedentary so I still have a good amount of fat left now that I'm down to 135)

I just finished the last of mine and I really will miss it. I don't think any of the other Lush lotions are meant to be firming.

Right now I'm just trying to get through my hoard of lotion (Lush and otherwise) so I'm not focusing on a firming lotion BUT I did some googling for you and it looks like Palmer's is a cruelty free brand that has a bust firming cream and a firming butter, I had a roommate once who used these products and they tend to be pretty fragrant (not necessarily in a bad way), as a warning. Acure Organics (also cruelty free) has a body firming lotion.

Unfortunately I haven't tried any of these but they seem to have pretty decent reviews. :) I hope this helps.

Palmer's Firming Butter seems to be the most popular choice; a lot of people report good results. I started using it about two weeks ago; I lotion my entire body every night after my post-workout shower, and I feel like it is doing some good. It will be a while longer before I know how effective it is.