Reddit reviews A Harvest Saved (Text)

We found 1 Reddit comments about A Harvest Saved (Text). Here are the top ones, ranked by their Reddit score.

A Harvest Saved: Francis O'Neill And Irish Music In Chicago Music Sales America Series This Highly Illustrated Study Details Daniel Francis O'neill's Extraordinary Career And His Crucial Role In The Preservation And Dissemination Of Irish Traditional Music And Contains Newly Discovered Information On This Unique Figure In Irish And Irish-american Cultural HistoryThis Highly Illustrated Study Details Daniel Francis O'neill's Extraordinary Career And His Crucial Role In The Preservation And Dissemination Of Irish Traditional Music And Contains Newly Discovered Information On This Unique Figure In Irish And Irish-american Cultural History

Check price on Amazon

1 Reddit comment about A Harvest Saved (Text):

u/Xenoceratops · 22 pointsr/musictheory

The music in that link is some garbage. The Irish ("Celtic") part:

Diatonic melodies.
Dorian, mixolydian, major, and minor modes. (These may also exist as pentatonic or hexatonic "gapped" variants.)
Parallel periods.
Repeated binary form (ABAB).
Traditional instruments: fiddle, whistle, uilleann pipes, concertina.
Meter. You're probably latching onto the compound meter stuff. Some of these rhythms are not really a part of that music, though. The rhythms are traditionally categorized by the type of dance they accompany (e.g., reel, hornpipe, jig, slip jig, slide, polka, mazurka), and meter is one component of that.

The not-so-Irish part:
All the other shit. Irish trad music is very melody-forward, and moreover tends to be heterophonic. Homophony and polyphony are foreign European elements.

You might try lurking around at The Session. Lots of Irish/English/Scottish/Welsh trad players over there.

Also read these:

Nicholas Carolan - A Harvest Saved: Francis O'Neill and Irish Music in Chicago

Gearóid Ó hAllmhuráin - O'Brien Pocket History of Irish Traditional Music