Reddit reviews Honey-Can-Do SFT-01254 10-Shelf Hanging Shoe Organizer, Natura, Natural
We found 2 Reddit comments about Honey-Can-Do SFT-01254 10-Shelf Hanging Shoe Organizer, Natura, Natural. Here are the top ones, ranked by their Reddit score.
Hangs for easy storage, hook and loop fastening fits over closet rod10 shelves, holds shoes or AccessoriesDurable canvas material, with reinforced seams10 shelves for shoesand Accessories
We have one of these that work out well. They're supposed to be for shoes but are great for organizing hats and scarves and don't take up too much closet space.
These are not the exact ones that I have because I can't remember the brand names of them, but they are the exact designs of each.
Rectangular. I love this one because it has heavy-duty velcro straps that hold it on the rod and I swear I could hang from those straps if I wanted to.
Circular. This one is OK. The hook is very open and fell off the rod when I first started loading my yarn into the pockets and spun it around, so I had to tie a ribbon around the open end and where it attaches to the organizer. It is holding quite a bit of chunky yarn at the moment and spins like a pinwheel with no resistance.
Out of the two that you were looking at, I would go with the over-the-door one just because of that hook that is on the hanging one. I don't trust those at all now.